A first external audit is an important milestone, whether the entity is being audited for the first time because of a statutory or contractual requirement, or in preparation for raising finance or bringing in new investors.
It matters most where the financial statements have never been audited before, because additional procedures may be needed on opening balances, the completeness of records and the consistency of the accounting policies applied.
It is also worth distinguishing a first audit of the financial statements from a first engagement with a new external auditor. Both fall within the concept of an initial audit engagement under the relevant auditing standards, even though the procedures required differ in each case.
Good preparation does more than make the auditor's work easier. It helps the finance team improve the quality of its accounting information, address weaknesses early and be better prepared for later reporting periods.
Why a first external audit is different
An initial audit differs from recurring engagements in parts of planning and in obtaining audit evidence. A new auditor needs to understand the entity, its environment and its accounting information system, assess the risks of material misstatement, and obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about opening balances.
The matters that most deserve management's attention are:
- Opening balances: documents and records supporting the balances brought forward from the prior period, so that the auditor can perform the procedures required by ISA 510.
- Understanding the business: information on activities, organisational structure, key processes, accounting systems and internal control.
- Financial reporting framework: confirming that the financial statements are prepared under the framework endorsed in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia that applies to the entity.
- Comparative information: confirming that prior-period figures are sound and disclosed in line with the relevant requirements.
Preparing for these areas early reduces delays and smooths the audit, without removing the auditor's responsibility to perform the procedures the standards require.
Step one: agree the audit framework and expectations
Before fieldwork starts, management and the external auditor should agree the terms of the engagement, including the objective and scope of the audit, the responsibilities of each party and the framework used to prepare the financial statements.
The key points to settle are:
- The financial reporting framework that applies to the entity.
- The financial period under audit and the requirements for comparative information.
- The timetable, and when information and documents will be provided.
- Who will coordinate with the audit team.
- Management's responsibility for preparing the financial statements and for internal control, and the auditor's responsibility for expressing an independent professional opinion.
These terms are recorded in the audit engagement letter, as required by ISA 210.
Step two: prepare the records and balances
The finance team should review its records before the audit begins, making sure that entries and reconciliations are complete and that significant transactions and balances are supported by documents.
The core areas to prepare are:
- General ledger: review account balances and prepare a trial balance after the necessary adjustments.
- Bank and cash: prepare bank reconciliations and resolve unexplained differences.
- Customers and suppliers: agree balances to the sub-ledgers, analyse ageing and assess whether allowances are needed.
- Fixed assets: update the asset register and review cost, depreciation, useful lives and related accounting estimates.
- Inventory: keep accurate quantity and cost records, organise the physical count and agree early with the auditor on count attendance where required.
- Related parties: identify related-party transactions, balances and commitments and prepare the required disclosures.
- Zakat and tax: reconcile zakat and tax balances and liabilities to the returns and supporting records, and assess the accounting treatment and disclosures required.
These steps should reflect the nature, size and risks of the business rather than be treated as a uniform list that applies equally to every entity.
Step three: organise the documents the audit needs
Providing documents in an organised way makes the audit smoother and reduces the time spent requesting and exchanging information.
We suggest that management:
- Appoint a coordinator for the audit team and for tracking information requests.
- Prepare a list of the documents requested by the auditor.
- Assign an owner and a target date to each document.
- Organise electronic files with clear names and defined versions.
- Check documents for completeness and consistency with the records before submitting them.
Core documents may include significant contracts, relevant minutes, statutory documents, financing agreements, reconciliations and accounting analyses, depending on the entity and the audit requirements.
Step four: review accounting policies and estimates
Documented accounting policies help management apply consistent treatment to similar transactions and make it easier to explain to the auditor how the financial statements were prepared.
Depending on the business, the topics to focus on include:
- Revenue recognition.
- Measuring inventory and determining its cost.
- Depreciation of fixed assets and estimates of useful lives.
- Impairment of assets.
- Measuring provisions and contingent liabilities.
- Related-party transactions and their disclosure.
Management should adopt appropriate policies and estimates under the applicable financial reporting framework, and document the significant judgements and assumptions behind them.
During the audit: structured communication with the auditor
Effective communication with the audit team helps resolve queries and clarify information as the work progresses.
We recommend that the finance team:
- Hold regular follow-up meetings as needed.
- Provide requested information and documents on the agreed dates.
- Discuss significant accounting matters and proposed adjustments before the audit is closed.
- Track open queries and unresolved matters.
- Review proposed adjustments and disclosures and assess them against the applicable framework.
Accounting decisions and the preparation and approval of the financial statements remain management's responsibility, while the external auditor keeps its independence and its responsibility for forming its professional opinion.
After the audit: using the findings
The value of an external audit does not end when the report is issued. Management can use the findings communicated to it to strengthen accounting information systems and improve internal control.
Under ISA 265, the auditor must communicate significant deficiencies in internal control identified during the audit to those charged with governance in writing and on a timely basis, and must communicate other deficiencies to management as the standards require.
Management should assess these findings, set priorities, assign responsibilities and follow up on corrective action.
An external audit should not, however, be treated as a comprehensive assessment of the effectiveness of all internal controls: the objective of a financial statement audit differs from that of a separate engagement to assess internal control.
An important note on independence
Some entities, especially those being audited for the first time, may need professional support in preparing financial statements or developing accounting policies and procedures.
Financial information preparation and advisory services must be distinguished from the independent external audit.
An external auditor providing additional services to an audit client may create threats to its independence, including a self-review threat. Those threats must be evaluated and the relevant professional requirements applied.
The nature of the support needed should therefore be defined, and whether the same firm may provide it should be confirmed before contracting. Management remains responsible for preparing the financial statements and for the related decisions.
In summary
Preparing for a first external audit is more than gathering documents. It is an opportunity to strengthen accounting discipline and the quality of financial information.
Effective preparation starts with settling the financial reporting framework and the engagement terms, continues through preparing balances, records and accounting policies, and ends with structured communication with the auditor and acting on the audit's findings.
The earlier preparation starts, the better placed the entity is to manage the audit efficiently and to provide the information needed for more reliable financial decisions.