Reviewing the financial statements is one of the audit committee's core responsibilities. It is an opportunity to assess the soundness and integrity of financial reporting, discuss significant accounting judgements and estimates, check that disclosures are adequate, and understand the risks that could affect the financial position and results.

Exercising this role does not mean re-preparing the financial statements or performing external audit procedures. Management is responsible for preparing the financial statements under the applicable financial reporting framework, while the external auditor expresses an independent professional opinion under the relevant standards.

The audit committee's responsibility is to exercise oversight, discuss significant matters, and give its opinion and recommendation to the board on the financial statements, in line with regulatory requirements and the committee's charter.

The practical questions below help committee members focus their discussion on the matters that matter most before making their recommendation.

1. Accounting judgements and estimates

Financial statements contain accounting estimates and judgements that can have a material effect on assets, liabilities and profit, such as inventory valuation, asset impairment, useful lives, expected credit loss allowances, and provisions and contingent liabilities.

These areas call for particular attention from the audit committee because they rely on assumptions and judgements that may involve a high degree of estimation uncertainty.

Suggested questions:

  1. Which accounting estimates and judgements had the greatest effect on this year's financial statements, and what key assumptions did management rely on?
  2. Have these estimates changed significantly since last year, and why?
  3. How sensitive are the financial results to changes in the assumptions used?
  4. Has management compared prior-period estimates with actual outcomes to assess their accuracy?
  5. Are there indications of management bias in selecting assumptions or applying accounting policies?
  6. Are the disclosures about significant estimates and sources of estimation uncertainty adequate and clear?

General answers, or answers not supported by appropriate analysis, may indicate that more discussion or evidence is needed before the committee forms its view on the financial statements.

2. Accounting policies and unusual transactions

Suggested questions:

  1. Have any accounting policies changed during the period? What justifies the change, and how does it affect the financial statements and their comparability?
  2. Has the entity entered into significant unusual or complex transactions, and how was their accounting treatment determined?
  3. Are there significant related-party transactions, and were they approved and disclosed in line with the applicable requirements?
  4. Are there transactions close to the period end that call for discussion of their timing or economic substance?
  5. Have the relevant accounting standards, interpretations and amendments that became effective during the period been applied?
  6. Are there transactions whose accounting treatment is disputed between management and the external auditor, and how was the disagreement resolved?

Related-party transactions deserve particular attention, especially where ownership and management overlap or where transactions fall outside the normal course of business. The committee should focus on the substance and terms of each transaction and the related approvals and disclosures.

3. Questions for the external auditor

Effective communication with the external auditor is central to the audit committee's work. The committee should allow independent and candid discussion of the significant matters that arose during the audit, including private sessions with the auditor without executive management present where needed.

Suggested questions:

  1. What were the main risks of material misstatement you identified, and how did you respond to them?
  2. Which accounting judgements and estimates required particular attention during the audit?
  3. Did you face significant difficulties in obtaining the information or evidence you needed?
  4. Were there significant disagreements with management over accounting policies, estimates or disclosures, and how were they resolved?
  5. Are there uncorrected misstatements, and what is their effect, individually and in aggregate, on the financial statements?
  6. Did you identify significant deficiencies in internal control, and what are their nature and potential effects?
  7. Are there matters that could affect the form of your opinion or require particular emphasis in your report?
  8. Are there matters concerning your independence or other services provided to the entity that the committee should be aware of?

It can be useful for the committee to close its discussion with an open question to the external auditor: are there any significant matters you believe the committee should be aware of before it makes its recommendation on the financial statements?

4. Going concern and subsequent events

Suggested questions:

  1. Has management assessed the entity's ability to continue as a going concern as required by the applicable financial reporting framework?
  2. What key assumptions underlie the cash flow, liquidity and financing forecasts?
  3. Are there events or conditions that may cast significant doubt on the entity's ability to continue as a going concern?
  4. Are there financing obligations falling due, or contractual covenants, that the entity may struggle to meet?
  5. Does management have plans to address liquidity or financing risks, and how realistic and achievable are they?
  6. Have significant events occurred after the reporting date that require adjustment of the financial statements or disclosure?
  7. Has the external auditor discussed management's going concern assessment and subsequent events, and what were its main findings?

It is important to distinguish subsequent events that provide evidence of conditions existing at the reporting date, which may require figures to be adjusted, from events arising after that date, which may require disclosure depending on their significance and nature.

5. Zakat, tax and regulatory matters

Suggested questions:

  1. Has the entity calculated zakat and income tax, as each applies, on the relevant statutory bases and requirements?
  2. Are there significant differences or adjustments between the zakat and tax returns and the financial statements, and why?
  3. Are there open assessments, objections or disputes with the Zakat, Tax and Customs Authority?
  4. How has management assessed the financial risks of these disputes, and has it considered the requirements for recognising provisions or disclosing contingent liabilities under the relevant accounting standards?
  5. Are there significant risks relating to VAT, withholding tax or real estate transaction tax, depending on the entity's activities?
  6. Are there other regulatory breaches or claims that could materially affect the financial statements or disclosures?
  7. Are there complex tax transactions or arrangements that call for a specialist professional assessment?

A zakat or tax claim or objection does not necessarily lead to a provision being recognised: the accounting treatment depends on the nature of the obligation and on whether the recognition, measurement and disclosure requirements of the applicable framework are met.

6. Presentation and disclosure

Financial statements can be numerically correct yet weak in their disclosures.

Suggested questions:

  1. Do the financial statements and accompanying notes present material information clearly and consistently with the applicable financial reporting framework?
  2. Are the significant risks facing the entity adequately disclosed, including liquidity and credit risk where relevant?
  3. Are there significant disclosures that are hard to understand or need further clarification?
  4. Is the financial information in the board report or other reports consistent with the financial statements, in line with the relevant requirements?
  5. Are related-party transactions, contingent liabilities and subsequent events appropriately disclosed?
  6. Is there material information whose omission, or burial within lengthy disclosures, could affect users' understanding of the financial statements?

Putting the questions to work

Good questions alone do not deliver effective oversight. They need to be supported by a clear process for answers, follow-up and appropriate action.

  • Before the meeting: send the questions and significant topics to the finance team and the external auditor in good time, and request the documents and analyses needed for the discussion.
  • During the meeting: focus on significant judgements, estimates and risks, and record the discussion, observations and key queries in the committee's minutes.
  • Where matters remain open: identify the additional information needed, who will provide it and when the matter should be resolved.
  • Before making the recommendation: make sure significant matters have been adequately discussed, and that any remaining matters have been resolved or clearly reported to the board with the committee's recommendation.
  • After the meeting: follow up on recommendations and corrective action, and add matters needing ongoing follow-up to the agenda of later meetings.

In summary

An audit committee's effectiveness is not measured by the number of its meetings or the volume of reports it receives, but by its ability to exercise effective oversight, ask the questions that matter, and discuss the judgements, estimates and risks that could affect the reliability of financial reporting.

These questions do not replace the professional judgement of committee members or the responsibilities of management and the external auditor. They offer a practical framework that helps focus the discussion on the most important matters and strengthens the quality of the recommendations made to the board.